(38)
$10
Login to create a wish list!

Description:

Hitting the Random Character button in a fighting game is the ultimate power move. 

Ordering a Fangamer Mystery Shirt is just as impressive, but much less dangerous. In exchange for leaving your order to fate you'll get a classic Fangamer shirt at our lowest prices ever—and save even more by purchasing multiple!

You pick the size*, and we'll take care of the rest. Your Mystery Shirts might be out-of-print designs or current ones with minor imperfections in the print or garment. They can't be returned or exchanged, and we don't take requests. But feel free to tell us in the comments which Fangamer shirts you already own and which games you like!

* Due to limited stock, sizes Unisex M-6X are limited to 1 per order.

* Women's shirts are largely comprised of our old garment, which ran a little small and has since been phased out for a new roomier version. We recommend choosing a size up when buying a women's size Mystery Shirt.

Reviews

38 reviews Write a Review
kyle h
Verified Buyer
2/18/2025
disappointing.
i received the ness shirt when i told them what franchises i liked. i thought i would get a spamton or celeste shirt but i didn't. disappointing.

Response from Fangamer:

Sorry to hear you didn't get what you were hoping for! Mystery shirt stock varies over time, and while we try to fill requests, it's not always possible.
Olivier L
Verified Buyer
11/29/2024
Jackpot !
Can't believe i've hit the jackpot and got an AWESOME Axiom Verge shirt !! I also got a pretty nice Risky Boots shirt from Shantae. Will probably order again :D
Zachary H
Verified Buyer
11/25/2024
Great shirt, worth the price
Amazing shirt! I seem to have gotten an unreleased/unlisted (I couldn’t find it under the artist’s products) Zelda shirt, which is a pleasant surprise. The print was slightly off center, but barely noticeable unless you’re looking for it. Came with a Stardew Valley Krobus sticker too! 100% worth the price.
Review image for Great shirt, worth the price
Andres
Verified Buyer
9/15/2024
¡Una maravillosa sorpresa!
tuve la oportunidad de comprar 4 camisas misteriosas y grata fue mi sorpresa al ver que ¡3 de ellas no estaban en el catalogo de la pagina!, todas son hermosas y me encanto que 2 de ellas hacian referencia a grandes franquicias que me gustan pero que no tienen presencia en la pagina; cuando pueda las volvere a comprar a ver que sorpresa me llevare.
Review image for ¡Una maravillosa sorpresa!
Katheryn K
Verified Buyer
5/19/2024
SO SO HAPPI!!!!! MUCH RECOMMEND!!!!
Goodness. I bought some mystery shirts purely because they were cheaper, and I originally was going to purchase the sans T shirt but gave up on it for the sake of money saving... IMAGINE MY SURPRISE WHEN I OPEN MY PARCEL AND FIND A SANS SHIRT!!!!!!! I was bracing myself for disappointment, since I'm not so lucky when it comes to these sorts of gambles... but I was VERY pleasantly surprised! I was flabbergasted, there is a video of me screaming over it for 5 minutes (basically me going "IT'S SANS!!! IT'S SANS!!! SANS!!! I LOVE YOU SANS!!!!"), I am overjoyed, just absolutely brimming with joy. I got another shirt in a size women's XS that was for a game called "Astroneer" which I haven't heard of, but the print is absolutely gorgeous so I do not mind :)! The Megalovania shirt I bought in a unisex size XS, which fits great!! (but I do prefer how the women's XS fits on me :3) Even though the mystery shirts are meant to be misprints or not-in-the-best-condition shirts, I couldn't find anything wrong with either of the shirts and I totally plan on wearing either as my go-to T shirts for whenever I have to go out. Too bad it's winter where I am now so I'll have to wait until it's less chilly to be able to flaunt my cool fangamer merchandise without having to pile on layers, but I am SO excited to wear my new shirts nonetheless! THANK YOU FANGAMER!! AND THANKS TO WHOEVER CHOSE THE MEGALOVANIA SHIRT TO PACK FOR ME!!!! MADE MY DAY :3
Review image for SO SO HAPPI!!!!! MUCH RECOMMEND!!!!